Homemade Peanut Butter Recipes: Unleash the Creamy Powerhouse in Your Kitchen

homemade peanut butter

Have you endlessly surfed the aisles to satisfy your craving for peanut butter that doesn’t have all the added sugar and other additives in it that are just right for you?

Here is an assortment of 10 homemade peanut butter recipes that will leave you with mouthwatering taste sensations – from the classic creamy to some super delicious ones.

Time to stay away from store-bought peanut butter that has added preservatives and be prepared to have some fun while making your peanut butter at home.

1. The Classic Superstar

Elevated Grilled Cheese
Β© iStock

The opportunity that this recipe brings is as close to the peanut butter fantasies for you. If you just pop some raw peanuts and roast them now and then, it will make them even tastier. Then grind them until they become creamy smooth. I always take salt to taste and if you want it a little sweeter for your taste, you can add a little honey or maple syrup. So, here is a quick homemade peanut butter. Try to use it in sandwiches, for dipping fruit, or just for eating from the jar. Keep it then in a sealed and clean glass jar for two or three weeks.

2. Go Nuts for Chocolate

nut butter
Β© myfitness

Hey, chocolate lovers! This recipe is for you but that does not mean forgetting those around you as well. This feels like regular peanut butter and ends up looking like lava cake. Finally, when all your peanuts are creased from blending, add a large spoonful of cocoa powder and stir it, to achieve that intensely flavorful chocolatey taste. Such homemade chocolate peanut butter would be great for spreading on waffles, less lethal to pancakes, and even for simple dipping of apples for the whole family.

Get it here

3. Honey Roasted Bliss

Β© iStock

Got a sweet tooth? This recipe is the perfect supply mission for the hardest of times. It takes away the mundane homemade peanut butter and adds an additional bit of sweetness to it. Here’s the trick: before roasting your peanuts, drip them in something sweet such as a light layer of honey. While roasting the coffee, it caramelises it, which means that the sugar-saturated flavour creates a fine combo with the taste of peanuts. But don’t over-roast them after drizzling the honey as you don’t want the resulting effect to be burnt. Drip this toasted peanut butter with honey on whole-grain bread or sprinkle it generously over fresh chunky berries for a tasty snack without regrets.

4. Getting Spicy with Sriracha

Β© iStock

Like a minor fury? This recipe’s for you! Normal homemade peanut butter is fused with a slightly different fire flavour. Here’s how: your roasted peanuts just need to be blended until you love their consistency. The time is now to stir in some sriracha sauce according to your taste buds. At first, just a little is fine then add until you find the right taste. This peanut butter is just more than a simple sweetener for delicious meals. Use it for the best as a spread on crackers or as little as a spoonful in your stir-fry for that shot of flavour.

5. Fruity Fun with Berries

Β© iStock

This recipe can be described as a gift for all the fruity cocktail lovers out there! It delivers a great idea of making your homemade peanut butter treat unique and fun to make with your family. Here’s how it works: mix freeze-dried strawberries or raspberries with the regular peanut butter until the all is merged in. These fruits will bring a burst of colour as well as intense flavour. They do this by adding saltiness and airiness without making your peanut butter too watery. Turn this fruity peanut butter into a wholesome cracker spread or a healthy alternative to beans with apple and banana slices.

6. Salty-Sweet with Pretzel Pieces

No-Bake Pretzel Bites
Β© iStock

If you’re looking for a taste sensation, you’ve found it! This recipe transforms your homemade peanut butter into something extraordinary with a mix of sweet and salty flavours. Here’s what you do: crush your favourite pretzels into small pieces and mix them gently into your creamy homemade peanut butter. The salty crunch of the pretzels works amazingly well with the rich taste of the peanut butter, giving it a satisfying texture. Use this pretzel peanut butter in sandwiches, on top of yoghurt, or just enjoy it straight from the spoon.

7. Tropical Twist with Coconut

Β© iStock

Have a quick dose of paradise without travelling with this homemade peanut butter recipe. In doing this, sprinkling coconut flakes and touching them with one hint of vanilla extract will make you feel that you’re on the beach. Be sure to see that you do not use sweetened grated coconut, but rather, you use unsweetened grated coconut to achieve a sweetness balance with the peanuts. Vanilla essence is my secret weapon that helps to highlight and add a sweet honey-like touch at the same time. Drop some ingredients on peanut butter, such as tropical fruit, and enjoy it on toast and waffles, or create some special peanut butter sweets.

8. Power Up with Chia Seeds

Creamy Chia Pudding
Β© iStock

Do you prefer to avoid all the extra stuff that comes in the name of peanut butter? Try adding chia seeds! Among healthy stuff, they include proteins, fibres and good fats such as seeds, which are pretty small. Do not bother with blending in them; just add them to your regular peanut butter recipe to reap the added benefits. The chia seeds not only give a crunchy flavour to the drink, but they also offer the feeling of satiation for hours. This new peanut butter is healthy before the workout and better be eaten for mid-day. For a special treat, my favourite way of eating it is with whole-wheat bread or crackers.

9. Mocha Magic with Coffee

Β© iStock

Coffee fans, listen up. This is a recipe that not only allows you to enjoy your coffee and peanut butter together but also, invites you to do it creatively. Just pour a shot of instant coffee mixed with some peanut butter or espresso into your homemade peanut butter to make this a taste bud sensational drink while waking yourself up with a caffeine boost. If you are crazy about coffee, add one or two teaspoons of crushed coffee beans to the ground coffee while blending. This peanut butter with the flavour of coffee might be one of the best things ever – use it to spread on waffles, pancakes, or for an on-the-go snack.

10. The Ultimate Nut Butter Blend

Nut Butter Blend
Β© iStock

Hey there peanut butter DIY lovers, ready to kick it up a notch with homemade peanut butter? There is something different about this recipe: blend and mix various nuts to get a nut butter-like one that you have never seen before. Begin with roasted peanuts and add nuts like cashews, almonds, or hazel. Experiment a bit with the quantities until you find the mixing ratio you like. Warm it up, spread it on toast, throw apple slices into it or stir it into a smoothie of your choice for the additional yummy taste.


These outstanding recipes of homemade peanut butter were prepared at home to satisfy your craving for delicious flavours.

It doesn’t matter whether you opt for the traditional experience or a mix of both, there will be a peanut butter that will match everyone’s tastes.

Just use your blender to make peanut butter at home with just these few ingredients and forget about store-bought products and make your snacks, smoothies, and treats that will be much better tasting.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long will homemade peanut butter stay fresh?

Limiting its exposure to sunlight can keep it fresh for at least a month. Refrigerating works best if you’re someone who doesn’t eat nutty spread that quickly. The oils present in homemade peanut butter can go rancid very quickly if left outside for a long time.

How healthy is homemade peanut butter?

Whether you buy your peanut butter from the store or make it yourself, it is a good source of many essential vitamins and minerals (Calcium, Iron, Potassium, Vitamin E, Vitamin B6, Magnesium, Manganese, and Zinc). – Maintain good cholesterol and blood pressure: due to the presence of oleic acid.

Can I eat homemade peanut butter every day?

Stick to the recommended serving size of two tablespoons, or close to that amount. Eating peanut butter daily could become an issue if someone is eating far too much of it and exceeding their daily saturated fat limit, per the Cleveland Clinic.